UPDATE:
Wiser and
Williams directed us to Senator Kerry's speech on faith and policy at
Pepperdine. Suspend your prejudice and
read it. He speaks truth.
Also, I buried this link in the body of the article, but please pay special attention to
VU's excerpts of Tom Fox's blog from Iraq. Last week, Iran’s Prime Minister, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, paid a call on Hugo Chavez, President of Venezuela. Both men take great umbrage with the U.S. and our current government. Chavez calls Castro his brother, and now Ahmadinejad is in the fraternity, too. Chavez is calling his southern neighbors together into a new version of an old theme, pan-South American social solidarity, and with leftists making good headway in many southwestern nations, he may be onto something. Chavez and Ahmadinejad are revolutionaries with a common enemy, and the Iranian and the Venezuelan are making smart plays in their neighborhoods to invest capital to build influence and to consolidate the collective power of allies. Saddam Hussein had no friends, but the U.S. may be in the midst of a triangulation, a flanking maneuver among ambitious socialists from the developing world, all with luscious oil reserves. Our government has not yet suggested that we might go to war with Venezuela, but “all options are on the table” for Iran.
In Time, a “senior administration official” says that the state department wants “to prevent a situation in which the president finds himself having to decide between a nuclear-armed Iran or going to war.” The administration says that it is determined to seek a diplomatic solution, but
we must wonder whether this President’s government can negotiate with Iran or Venezuela or Syria or Israel or North Korea in a post-Iraq world. The prime problem with this administration is its propensity to think in terms of two options. Either you are with us or against us. Either tow the line or appease the enemy. Nations are good or evil. Give up your rights and keep the complaints down, or you will die at the hands of a suicide bomber. Evil dictators are evil. We are good. We do not do deals with evil dictators. Decide between a nuclear-armed Iran or go to war.
These are false choices. Two great flaws plague this administration, a lack of humility and a lack of creativity. For Christians, these qualities are inherent to our faith, our tradition and the teachings of our Lord. With out humility and without creativity, complexity distills to naiveté, at best, and reckless, at worst. Our President claims Christ but has not demonstrated these Christian attributes very well.
As we stare down new crises by the day, many of our own making, let us Christians implore our government to heed some prophecy: I desire mercy, not sacrifice. Do justly, love mercy and walk humbly with your God. Blessed are the peacemakers and the meek. Love your neighbor as yourself.
I am not a pacifist but a just-war pragmatist, yet we must be driven by the Spirit of Christ Who desires peace. We have some choices to make which will affect the live of millions of innocents. War is no abstraction, however far from home. We need not abandon our security, our prosperity or our sovereignty to avoid war. We must be more creative, and we must be humble. Jesus disarmed his religious rivals with truth and goodness that they did not expect. He did not walk brashly into their traps and retaliate when they attacked him. Instead, Jesus surprised their preconceptions. This is good foreign policy strategy for this mighty nation.
Mercy. Let us extend our wealth to relieve the suffering of the poorest masses of humanity. Let us engender good will and influence by our compassion, not our might. Moreover, let us do no more harm than we have done to millions of people in poverty and fear as a result of our preemptive wars. We need not bomb Iran to keep it from getting the Bomb anymore than we needed to level Fallujah to contain Saddam Hussein. Mamas die. Daddies die. Babies die. Little girls run from soldiers and car bombs to learn to read. We have the power to build, not only to destroy, and the use of our power and wealth turns simply on the motives we chose to suffer.
We have not shown mercy in Iraq. Humility.
Let us receive insight from others closer to our perceived enemies. Let us at least consider their grievances and shape. Let us admit that we may not be the only righteous people, if any are to be found here at all. Let us take moral counsel from weaker nations. Let us not forget that we once were weak too. Let us not think that we are immune from blood or judgment. Let us remember the Kings of Divine Right who lost their heads to an oppressed underclass. The people still may rise; history continues.
Love. Let us not be the first to strike, even if the threat is imminent. Let us never preempt so that we never surrender the high ground. Let us weigh the value of life and families, even our enemies’, or our enemies’ neighbors, more than we value our own wealth and affluence. Our national interests should be morality, compassion, charity and defense of the defenseless.
Torture cannot be loving, and the
absence of love is evil. Creativity. Let us act to forge a better world built in progress, education, investment and wisdom, not in war. We can craft solutions that protect our own ends while contemplating our opponents’ interests. Only rarely must we go to war. Negotiation is not weakness. Negotiation is reconciliation. Negotiation takes maturity. Negotiation is peacemaking. Negotiation preempts death. Talk to Iran. Talk to Syria. Talk to Castro. Talk to Venezuela. Talk to North Korea. Engagement yields insight and information, and knowledge informs negotiation. Negotiation is not weak. Negotiation is smart.
Be certain; in international politics, never are two options the only way. Never. The President doesn’t have two options, good or evil; he has a thousand and one options, along the spectra, from evil to good, from unworkable to effective, from smart to stupid, from unilateral to consensus, from military to economic to political, to personal to spiritual. Nuance does not imply weakness. Nuance and subtlety demonstrate a realistic grasp of grown up problems.
May I now go on the record as new opponents gather on our shores and plot our demise, while dangers multiply and enemies call their guerillas to arms. Now is the season for wisdom, creativity, love, humility and courage. We should not wage war on any of these enemies, because victory does not require war. War imposes too great a cost on our own souls and the lives of those we would shatter. If we go to war against Iran, North Korea, Venezuela or Syria, we will have failed.